Does Peanut Butter Have Sugar?: The Sweet Truth

Opened peanut butter jar with sugar on side

Welcome! Here we will unlock the mystery behind the sugar in peanut butter. If you’ve ever wondered whether peanut butter contains sugar, you’re not alone a.

Today, we’ll walk you through what you need to know about the sugar content of peanut butter. Specifically, we’ll inform you if it contains sugar and if so, how much.

Sugar in Peanut Butter

Does peanut butter have sugar in it? Well, it depends. While some varieties of peanut butter do contain sugar, not all of them do. Let’s explore further:

The table below shows a sampling of some of the top peanut butter brands at grocery stores. It also reflects the sugar content, if any in each product. This information should give you an idea of how common or uncommon sugar is in peanut butter.

As the table shows, most peanut butters have around 2.5 grams of total sugar and about 1 gram of added sugar, on average. While this is not a huge sample size, most peanut butter products have similar sugar content to what you see below.

Peanut Butter ProductServings SizeTotal Sugars(g)Added Sugars(g)
365 By Whole Foods – Creamy2 Tbsp. (32g)2g0g
365 By Whole Foods – Crunchy2 Tbsp. (32g)2g0g
Crazy Richard’s – Crunchy2 Tbsp. (32g)3g2g
Jiff – Creamy2 Tbsp. (33g)3g2g
Jif – Natural Creamy2 Tbsp. (33g)4g2g
Justin’s – Classic2 Tbsp. (32g)2g0g
Kirkland – Organic Creamy2 Tbsp. (32g)1g0g
Koeze – Crunchy2 Tbsp. (32g)2g0g
Kroger – Creamy2 Tbsp. (32g)4g2g
Kroger – Crunchy2 Tbsp. (32g)4g2g
MaraNatha – Organic Creamy No Added Salt or Sugar2 Tbsp. (32g)2g0g
Peter Pan – Creamy2 Tbsp. (32g)3g2g
Santa Cruz Organic – No Stir Dark Roasted Crunchy2 Tbsp. (32g)1g0g
Skippy – Creamy2 Tbsp. (32g)3g3g
Skippy – Extra Crunchy Super Chunk2 Tbsp. (32g)3g3g
Smucker’s – Natural Creamy2 Tbsp. (32g)2g0g
Average2 Tbsp.2.56g1.1g

Recommended Sugar Intake

Health agencies provide recommendations for added sugar and not total sugar. Remember that total sugar is all sugar in the food including natural and added sugar. Added sugar is simply the sugar that the manufacturer adds to the product.

The American Heart Association (AHA) recommends the following for maximum added sugar intake per day:

  • Daily added sugar intake for men should not exceed 9 teaspoons, which is approximately 36 grams or 150 calories.
  • Women have a lower recommended limit of 6 teaspoons, equivalent to around 25 grams or 100 calories per day.

Overall, the added sugar content is low and not a concern for most healthy people who eat peanut butter in moderation. There are certainly plenty of options for brands of peanut butter with zero added sugar and minimal total sugar.

Tips for Choosing Peanut Butter:

If you’re looking to avoid excessive added sugars in peanut butter, here are some tips:

  1. Read the Labels: Take a moment to read the ingredients list and nutrition facts panel on the jar. Look for peanut butter with no added sugar or choose those with lower sugar content.
  2. Check for Natural Varieties: Opt for natural peanut butter, which often contains only peanuts, for a sugar-free option.
  3. Portion Control: Moderation is key! Peanut butter, even without added sugar, is still high in calories. Stick to recommended serving sizes to enjoy its benefits without overdoing it.

Why Be Mindful of Sugar in Peanut Butter?

Being mindful of the sugar content in foods, including peanut butter, is essential for overall health. Consuming excessive amounts of added sugars can lead to various health issues, such as weight gain, tooth decay, and increased risk of chronic diseases like diabetes and heart disease.

Selecting lower-sugar or sugar-free options allows you to enjoy the goodness of peanut butter without the drawbacks. The good news is that most peanut butter products have minimal added sugars.

Final Thoughts

Some varieties of peanut butter do contain added sugar, while others do not. However, all contain some natural sugar found in the peanuts that are used to make peanut butter.

By reading labels and making informed choices, you can select peanut butter that aligns with your dietary preferences and health goals. Remember, moderation is key, so enjoy your peanut butter in appropriate portions if you wish to live a healthy lifestyle.

Remember, knowledge is power, and understanding the foods we consume empowers us to make healthier choices. So go ahead, spread that peanut butter on your toast or dip your apple slices into it, and savor its deliciousness without any added sugar worries. Stay curious, stay healthy!

Scroll to Top