How Long Does Peanut Butter Last?

Question: How long does peanut butter last?

Peanut butter is one of those products that you tend to buy, forget about it, and don’t necessarily question its freshness when you go to use it again. Many of use likely assume peanut butter stays good indefinitely or well past when you have consumed the last bite. However, how long does peanut butter really last?

Peanut Butter Shelf Life

While it would be nice if peanut butter lasted forever, it actually does turn rancid. However, peanut butter’s low moisture percentage coupled with a high oil concentration does not offer an inviting environment for bacteria to thrive. It is unlikely that you would open your peanut butter and one day notice a patch of mold like you would in something like sour cream.  Rather, the concern is with the rancidity of the fats from exposure to oxygen. Peanut butter will taste off once it becomes rancid from oxygen exposure.

The length of time peanut butter will remain edible depends on how it is stored. An unopened jar with the original sealing will last much longer than an opened peanut butter.

Unopened regular peanut butter left in the cupboard or pantry (dark, cool environment) for the majority of its storage time will  last for approximately 9 months to a 1 year from when produced.

Opened regular peanut butter will keep for only about 3-4 months in the pantry and you may squeeze another 3-4 months out of it if you keep it in the refrigerator.

Natural peanut butter maintains a much shorter shelf life than regular peanut butter. Unopened natural peanut butter will last about three months in the cupboard and up to six months in the refrigerator. Additionally, it will keep roughly 4-6 months in the refrigerator once opened.

The above shelf life timeframes are estimates and ultimately peanut butter’s rancidity depends on many factors like the environment, level of exposure to oxygen, product ingredients, etc.  In addition to the above estimates, we took a look at few actual peanut butter manufacturers to see what they had to say about their peanut butter’s shelf life. Here is what they said:

Jif– “Unopened and stored in a cool, dry area, Jif peanut butter will last for about two years (refer to the Best If Used By date). After opening, you can keep Jif peanut butter about three months on the pantry shelf. If unopened, Jif To Go™ peanut butter and Jif Natural peanut butter spread will each last one year (refer to the Best If Used By date).”

Smuckers – “It is the nature of packaged food products to experience some slight color and flavor degradation during extended storage. Products should be stored in cool temperatures (50° F to 60° F is preferable, but it should not exceed 75° F for extended periods) and should not be exposed to direct sunlight. Most of our fruit spreads and ice cream toppings have a shelf life of 24 months from the date of production, and our peanut butters have a shelf life of nine months from the date of production. However, in order to obtain maximum color and flavor of our products, we do recommend consuming them within one year of the purchase date.”

Adams – “Unopened or opened, Adams Peanut Butter has a nine month shelf life once produced. We recommend using the product by the Best If Used By date stamped on the back label.”

Reply